Hunting in the Year 2020: Fair Chase

By Shane Reynolds

I made a recent post on a social media website in a national group that I belong to of a teal hunt in Eagle Lake. The comments from some of the group’s members were extremely nasty to put it mildly. I understand that as a hunter I’m in the minority in this country. Maybe not in Texas, but at the national level that is certainly true. The debate that ensued allowed me an opportunity to try to educate the non-hunters in the group, and at the same time, allowed pro-hunters and anglers to chime in. It was refreshing to see quite a few people in that group express themselves about the importance of hunting and fishing in their lives and articulate their position.  

Hunting is a human activity that has been with us since the dawn of man. It is practiced today by millions of people worldwide and remains a longstanding outdoor tradition, out of both recreation and necessity. However, its perception in modern society has become muddled as more people drift away from the need to hunt, fueled by misconceptions of what it means to harvest an animal. Today, we hunters are a minority. Therefore, it is now more important than ever that we adhere to a strict code of conduct which requires respect for the animal and builds equity in the minds of a public that is becoming increasingly hostile to this lifestyle.

The concept of fair chase in hunting has been around for well over 100 years. In 1887, at the very first meeting of the Boone and Crockett Club, the founding members discussed the need for a new standard of ethical hunting. The name given to this standard by the club was Fair Chase, and it has become a guiding principle for the pursuit of wild game — a code that any hunters I know and hunt with have applied to their life-long passion. It dictates that hunting should be conducted by responsible people who hold themselves accountable to a higher personal standard that extends above and beyond the law. The Fair Chase principle contains three fundamental components: Intrinsic Value, Moral Legitimacy and Ethics. I believe that an understanding of Fair Chase in today’s world is important for an accurate representation of hunting’s place in our society, and raising awareness to its truth will protect the sportsman heritage for those yet to experience it.

Intrinsic Value
This is the understanding that every being has value in its own right which is not derived from the human benefit they can or cannot be used for.

The principles I hunt by have developed over time, and the first I chose to live by was responsibility, born out of respect for the wildlife. In my youth, I was fascinated with the nature of animals — I’ve always enjoyed watching and observing animals in their natural habitat. 

My father loved to hunt duck, and even before I was old enough to carry a gun in the field, I walked alongside him and my interest in wildlife focused on the animals we could hunt. This fascination evolved into an appreciation for game animals, specifically. Just laying eyes on these creatures in the wild was a precious victory and notched a memory. Once I was of age and earned the right to hunt, I harvested my first duck, and appreciation transformed into responsibility. 

I can recall my father’s early lessons about “this is how we do things and this is what we don’t do.” Although I didn’t connect the dots at the time, I later realized he was teaching for the sake of continuance — teaching me to respect the privilege to hunt so we can continue hunting for generations to come.

Moral Legitimacy
Some have emotional qualms about wildlife being killed for any reason. It appears that these same people are unconcerned if wildlife dies at the behest of nature, just as long as hunters are not involved, and certainly not if they enjoy it. This ideology stands ground regardless of the fact that the source of enjoyment is from the process and the effort involved in the hunt, rather than pulling a trigger or drawing a bow.

This raises an important question: Do we care more about the game itself or just our ability to hunt it? The answer used to be simple but is now clouded in the current climate of hunting resistance. It is easy to get caught up defending something we like to do and lose sight of the animals we pursue. There simply must be a moral legitimacy to hunting if it is to remain socially acceptable. Everyone values wildlife in their own way, but a deep connection is forged while engaged in the hunt of a wild creature. Bringing a harvest home to provide nourishment for oneself and loved ones creates a level of respect for an animal that only hunting can truly provide.

True sportsmen must always hunt hard and fair, with honor and purpose, never taking wild game or the opportunity to hunt them for granted, and ensuring a future for both. This leads to the ethical treatment of game in their natural habitat and to hunters becoming participants with wildlife rather than conquering it for some other reason.

Ethics
A hunter’s values, what motivates us and how we conduct ourselves, shapes society’s opinion of hunting. If we falter while striving for excellence in the field, the public will lose faith in Fair Chase. Traditions could be at risk if a majority of citizens develop a negative perception of hunting and fail to recognize the benefits provided to wildlife populations. We must not allow this to happen.

When I pursue an animal, I believe that it deserves my best and most honest effort. Cutting corners to make hunting easier and to assure a successful outcome undermines the unique nature of the pursuit, which offers “no guarantees.” By definition, to hunt is to pursue, which may or may not result in a kill. Any animal I take deserves to die quickly and humanely, just as much as they deserve to live wild and free. How an animal lives is just as important as how it dies. Fair Chase stresses the importance of hunting wild, free-ranging game animals as opposed to those confined without a chance to elude the hunter. This is where responsibility to myself and the game I seek connects.

Fair Chase is the confluence of intrinsic value, moral legitimacy and ethics. A conversation about ethics in hunting, the use of wildlife and the land where wildlife lives is pertinent to the public image of hunters and hunting. As sportsmen and women, we each carry an individual and collective set of values with us into the field, teachings that are instilled from fathers, mothers, mentors and personal experience that light the paths of right and wrong. These values are deeply rooted in that which makes us human. Our treatment of the wildlife we pursue and the environment in which they live are also linked to the purpose for which the game is harvested: for sustenance and fellowship. Whether it is for food, the experience of the chase, the accumulation of fond memories, or all of the above, hunting ethics are also about continuance.

History has proven that our society will eliminate or at least greatly diminish those activities seen as unethical. Therefore, society at large must be assured that hunting is something more than killing, and that hunting does not risk, but rather ensures the survival of the hunted. Through the concept of Fair Chase and hunting ethics, hunting transcends mere killing and becomes something more. That “something more” is a combination of the expectations of people, coupled with a binding contract on the part of the hunter to behave in a manner that honors both hunting and the animals pursued. The result will be a continuing social relevance for hunting in a modern world and the continued survival of the hunted in a truly wild state.

As a hunter, I value the opportunity to talk to others and educate people about the importance that hunting has in my life. The opportunity to commune with nature and the peace it brings to my life is something that many of my fellow hunters understand. The fellowship opportunities that exist on hunting and fishing trips with members and their guests is a component of my job I value greatly. I hope to see a few of you on our trips the Club offers! Onward!

Shane Reynolds is the Director of Outdoor Recreation at The Clubs of Cordillera Ranch. He can be reached at 210.616.6051 or sreynolds@cordilleraranch.com.

You Might Also Enjoy....

Member Services

Inspired and Engaging Retreats

When booking a company retreat, team building exercise or business conference, what better way to make connections and share ideas than in Cordillera’s captivating natural setting.

Read More »